Sgt. Preston's
Sgt. Preston's Sgt. Preston's spacer
Sgt. Preston's spacer

Yep, it's true...the ever-popular, often-imitated Original Schooner Night beer special started right here at Sgt. Preston's.

Here's how it works: On Monday nights, purchase an Original Schooner for $6.50 or our mini-pitcher for only $5.50

Then, bring back your Schooner or mini-pitcher on Mondays and receive domestic draft refills for only $2.00. Can't beat that, eh?

restaurant lounge entertainment lafayette

April 21st
Brian Koning

Buffalo

Sgt. Preston's Food Menu

Click here to open a PDF version of our menu.
Please note: Prices and menu selection subject to change without notice. Menu shown here subject to current restaurant pricing.

The Sarge's Famous
Chicken Wings

The Sarge’s Mild Buffalo Pub Sauce • Spicy Lambo Sauce or Wing Sauce of the Month
Served with choice of carrots or celery, ranch or bleu cheese dressing

Combination Basket
A tasty helping of our favorite apps - Chicken Strips, Onion Rings and Cheese Curds served with weakness sauce

Stuffed Mushrooms
Succulent crab stuffed mushroom buttons broiled and topped with gooey provolone cheese

Quesadilla
A large flour tortilla grilled with tomato, green onion, jalapeño and Cheddar Jack cheese. Served with a side of our house-made Fiesta sauce

Spinach & Artichoke Dip
The Sarge’s creamy recipe, topped with grated Romano cheese and served with your choice of warm French bread slices or crunchy tortilla chips

Preston’s Hot Wing Dip
Our one-of-a-kind spicy Lambo sauce blended with cream cheeses, shredded chicken, and green onions • Served with tortilla chips

Potato Skins
Hollowed Idaho potatoes smothered with shredded Cheddar-Jack cheese, crispy bacon bits and green onions • Served with a side of sour cream

Crab Cakes
Crab rounds, grilled to golden perfection • Served with the Sarge’s Fiesta sauce

Nacho Plate
Crunchy tortilla rounds piled high with shredded cheese, jalapeño peppers, black olives, green onions, tomatoes and your choice of meat • Served with salsa and sour cream

Cheese & Vegetable Plate
Freshly-cut vegetables and cheese cubes served with Ranch dressing

Cheese Curds
A Canadian favorite, golden fried and served with weakness sauce

Chicken Strips
Juicy chicken tenders served with a side of our signature weakness sauce

Clam Strips
A hearty helping of tasty clam strips golden fried to perfection, and served with cocktail sauce

Make these apps a meal by adding fries and your choice of Coleslaw, Cottage Cheese, or Applesauce for just $1.25

Back to top of Menu

Coleslaw (Creamy or Sweet & Sour) • Cottage Cheese • Side Salad • Applesauce • Steamed Veggie of the Day • Wild Rice • Baked Potato (after 5pm) • Garlic Toast • Onion Rings • Preston’s Fries (Steak or Shoestring)

The Sarge’s Sauces: Ranch • Fiesta Sauce • Honey Mustard • White Barbeque Sauce • Weakness Sauce • Buffalo • Lambo

Back to top of Menu

Brisket Chili
Our own award-winning recipe of hearty beef brisket and chili mixings

Soup of the Day
Ask about our daily soup selection

Back to top of Menu

Garden Salad
Fresh salad mix with tomato, green onion, celery, cucumber, mushroom and radish


Chef Salad
Garden salad, shredded Cheddar-Jack cheese, ham, turkey and egg slices

Grilled Chicken Salad
Garden salad, shredded Mozarella cheese and your choice of chicken: Plain • Buffalo • Spicy Lambo • Teriyaki • Cajun • Crispy

Taco Salad
Fresh salad mix topped with green onion, tomato, shredded Cheddar-Jack cheese, sour cream and your choice of chicken or spicy Mexican beef • Served with tortilla chips

Black & Bleu Salad
A bed of Romaine lettuce topped with thin sliced New York strip, tomato, green onion, mushroom and Bleu cheese crumbles • Served with Bleu cheese dressing

Rotini Pasta Salad
Tri-colored pasta with tomatoes, cucumbers and grated Romano cheese

Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed with Parmesan cheese, Egg Beaters, cracked pepper, anchovies, grated Romano cheese and the Sarge’s Caesar dressing

The Sarge’s House Dressings: Bleu Cheese • Honey Mustard • Balsamic Vinaigrette • Ranch • Caesar • Poppyseed • 1000 Island • Stagecoach French

Back to top of Menu

All wraps served with cottage cheese

Fiesta Wrap
A Preston’s favorite! Our juicy Cajun chicken breast sliced and tossed with Cheddar-Jack cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, green onion and secret Fiesta sauce

Grilled Chicken BLT Wrap
Our juicy grilled chicken breast tossed with bacon, Romaine lettuce, tomato, Cheddar-Jack cheese and creamy ranch dressing

Steak Wrap
Grilled New York Strip, sliced and tossed with shredded Cheddar-Jack cheese, grilled onion and green pepper • Served with the Sarge’s Fiesta sauce

Pulled Pork Tacos
Our own delectable creation - three soft taco shells piled high with tender pulled pork, Mozzarella cheese, lettuce, green onion and creamy white BBQ sauce

Preston's Tacos
Three soft taco shells stuffed with shredded lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese, a side of salsa and sour cream • Spicy Mexican beef, choice of chicken, or grilled steak

Back to top of Menu

All burgers served with steak fries

The Preston Burger
Our pride and joy - our house specialty half-pound certified angus beef

Canadian Burger
Canadian Bacon, Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and weakness sauce

Black & Bleu Burger
Blackened seasoning, grilled mushrooms, and Bleu cheese crumbles

Jammin’ Jalapeño Burger
Smoked Gouda cheese, crispy bacon and savory Jalapeño jam

Patty Melt
Melted Swiss cheese and grilled onions served hot on grilled Rye

Lafayette’s Original Buffalo Burger One-third pound of 100% juicy ground Bison

Back to top of Menu

All sammies served with steak fries

HOT SAMMIES

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
An Indiana staple hand-cut, tenderized and served on a brioche bun • Choose grilled or breaded

Steak Sandwich
Our hand-cut ribeye steak chargrilled and served on a French roll

French Dip
Thinly sliced roast beef piled high on a fresh French roll, served with a side of house-made Au Jus

Reuben
A mountain of your choice of lean corned beef or juicy turkey meat topped with 1000 Island dressing on grilled rye bread

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo, Spicy Lambo, Teriyaki, Cajun or Plain

Spinach & Artichoke Chicken Sandwich
Our savory chicken breast smothered under our spinach & artichoke dip and melted provolone cheese on grilled sourdough bread

Preston's Club
Join the club with a triple decker of deli ham, turkey and crispy bacon on toasted sourdough with lettuce, tomato and mayo

Turkey Supreme
Deli turkey piled high with avocado, cucumber, sprouts, lettuce and tomato on your choice of bread

Grilled Veggie Sandwich
A bed of fresh cucumbers, sprouts, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and mushroom on your choice of grilled Sourdough, 12-Grain or Light Rye bread

Grilled Cheese
The Sarge’s go-to cold weather fix - two choices of cheese melted between your choice of grilled bread

Tuna Melt
Fresh tuna salad served on grilled sourdough with your choice of cheese

COLD SAMMIES

BLT • Chicken Salad • Ham • Roast Beef • Turkey • Tuna Salad
All served on Sourdough or Wheat bread with potato chips and dill spear

Back to top of Menu

All entrees served with Salad or House-made Soup, Garlic Toast and choice of Side

New York Strip
Thick, 14oz New York strip, hand-cut, trimmed and chargrilled to your liking

Ribeye
Tender, marbled 14oz choice ribeye, hand-cut, trimmed and grilled to your liking

Grilled Chicken
Plain, Cajun, Teriyaki, Buffalo or Spicy Lambo • Served on a steamy bed of wild rice

Smothered Chicken
Choice of chicken smothered with Provolone cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms and green peppers

Center-cup Pork Loin Chop
Juicy center-cut, butterflied loin, served with a side of tasty applesauce

Salmon Filet
Fresh, grilled Salmon smothered with a cilantro lime glaze

Catfish Filet
2 hearty filets coated in a cornmeal breading, golden fried and served with tartar sauce and lemon wedges

House-Made Stuffed Shrimp
Large shrimp stuffed with tender crab meat, bread crumbs, herbs and spices, coated with a buttery glaze then broiled to perfection

Back to top of Menu

Preston’s Homemade Bread Puddin’
A Preston’s tradition - topped with our sticky Whiskey Sauce and Whipped Topping

Back to top of Menu

Coke • Diet Coke • Sprite • Ginger Ale • Lemonade • XXX Root Beer •Fresh Brewed Iced Tea • Regular & Decaf Coffee • Hot Chocolate • Hot Apple Cider • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice • Fresh Squeezed Grapefruit Juice

Back to top of Menu

Sgt. Preston's spacer